Seldon Crisis: Beyond Foundation
Seldon Crisis: Beyond Foundation
The Dead Hand and the Living Will
0:00
-21:10

The Dead Hand and the Living Will

Does it take "great man" to change history?
A symbolic digital painting in a 2:1 landscape format illustrating the tension between determinism and free will. On the left, a massive, weathered stone hand lies partially buried in a desolate landscape under a stormy sky, symbolizing the "Dead Hand" of fate and control. Faint lines etched into the ground suggest a predetermined path. On the right, a lone human figure stands with arms raised, bathed in radiant golden light, as vibrant, branching pathways emerge from beneath their feet and spread outward, representing choice, agency, and divergent futures. The two sides blend at the center, evoking a dynamic interplay between inevitability and possibility.

We go a little deeper on the theme of The General, the opposing forces of psychohistorical determinism vs the futile efforts of Bel Riose to exert his free will against it. Bringing this into our current universe, we talk about Thomas Carlisle's "Great Man" theory of history and some of the pushback against it. Your host then takes it into the personal realm with some reflections on a couple of modern candidates for "Great Man" status in reflecting on his past.

Transcript: Web (Read/Listen) | PDF | MS Word

Great Man Theory of History (Wikipedia)

‘The smartest person in any room anywhere’: in defence of Elon Musk, by Douglas Coupland (Guardian)

The Ministry for the Future, Kim Stanley Robinson (Amazon)
Kim Stanley Robinson: a climate plan for a world in flames (Financial Times)

Why Go to Space? To Save Humanity … and Our Earth, by Wilson da Silva (Medium)

The Mars Society (Website)

Want to help me make these shows? Please consider becoming a patron!

Discussion about this episode

User's avatar

Ready for more?